WATCH: Players Answer "Would You Rather" Halloween-Themed Questions

Would you rather...walk through a graveyard at midnight or spend the night in an abandoned house? Dunk for apples or carve a jack-o-lantern? Eat six fish eyeballs or eat a small frog?

Find out how Edwin Cerrillo, Brandon Servania, Reggie Cannon, Jacori Hayes, Thomas Roberts and Bryan Reynolds answered.